Commentary on DVD releases, both old and new. There is a lot to like about the digital realm and in addition to examining specific titles, we will also discuss the merits of new technology like Blu-Ray and HD-DVD, as well as digital downloading.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

DVD Review: That 70s Show Season 6

That 70s Show followed the example of the great Richard Linklater film Dazed and Confused the way Happy Days followed American Graffiti. That 70s Show didn't include any of the same actors from the movie, but the setting was very similar: Late high school years of a group of friends who encounter not only life lessons but the amusing trends and events of the late 1970s.

The sixth season of the show, which aired in 2003-2004, begins with the gang just graduated from high school and stepping out into the real world. Eric, the show's central character (played by Topher Grace), has decided to postpone college to help out around the house, where his father Red (Kurtwood Smith) has suffered a heart attack and can't work. It's worth noting that Red's heart attack was brought on by his daughter Laurie (Christina Moore, who replaced Lisa Robin Kelly in the role) marrying foreign exchange student Fes (Wilmer Valderrama) so that he could stay in the country since his student visa was set to expire upon his graduation.

Smith's Red Foreman is a rarity on television sitcoms: A father who's not a bumbling idiot. Red is a strong male figure in the show, presenting an old fashioned sense of masculinity that comes from his days as a former soldier in Korea. Contrast him with Bob (Don Stark), the Foremans' next door neighbor, who exhibits all the softness and silly traits that television fathers usually have. Bob also engages in every 70s trend that comes along, from hair perms to swinging to nudism.

The sixth season is interesting because it lets the characters grow out of their high school years and into young adults. In some cases, we see them move on and mature, as Kelso (Ashton Kutcher) joins the police academy and Hyde and Jackie (Danny Masterson, Mila Kunis) end their immature courting rituals and become a couple. Donna (Laura Prepon) starts college, but finds she can't leave Eric behind.

The DVDs do a nice job of representing the show, with clean transfers, promo spots for each episode and a few extra features. This isn't a lavish treatment, like the one given to a show like The Twilight Zone, but it is far better than what was just done for the second season of Happy Days. The DVD package has been made smaller this time around, with two double-disc slim cases inside a sleeve.

That 70s Show is a great program that mixed sharp, funny writing with good characters and a great premise. The show launched the careers of Grace (recently seen in Spider-Man 3, and so good in In Good Company) and Kutcher (who has had several film hits), and did something uncommon for sitcoms of its time: it broke boundaries. How many other shows would have the nerve to have its main teenage characters having sex and smoking pot as much as possible? While the sixth season may not be the show's peak, it is still very good, and this DVD collection is a nice addition.

More info: That 70s Central

Thursday, May 3, 2007

DVD Review: Happy Days Season 2


When Happy Days premiered in 1974, viewers might have thought it was going to be the television version of the 1973 hit movie American Graffiti by George Lucas. After all, M*A*S*H came to the small screen in 1972 from the feature film of 1970. Happy Days had the same focus on cars and rock and roll from the 1950s that Graffiti did, and it even starred Ron Howard, who played one of Graffiti's central characters. In many ways, the show was the small-screen Graffiti, despite taking place some six years earlier, during the height of the Eisenhauer administration.

The good news was that Happy Days, for the first few years at least, performed admirably. It presented a view of life in 1950s America that was nostalgic for some, albeit not the snapshot in time that Graffiti was of Lucas' California teenage years. Howard played Richie Cunningham, and served at the audience's focus. As he gathered life experience in the show, viewers saw events through his eyes. With his friends Ralph and Potsie and his family (father Howard, mother Marion and sister Joannie), Richie's life was the center of the universe for the show. As time went on, a minor character named Fonzie gained popularity and became the show's star, but in the first two seasons at least, Fonzie was still a supporting character used to give Richie's life more diversity. Howard's Graffiti co-star Cindy Williams (in photo, above) even guest-starred on the show and went on to be one of the leads in the spin-off Laverne & Shirley.


Season 2 is among the show's finest years. There's still an innocence and a novelty to the show that it would lose in later years (such as the infamous "jumping of the shark" event that has gained a cultural significance all it's own). In the 1974-1975 season (which seems to take place in 1955-1956), Richie finds out what it's like to live on his own, have his first car, participate in the ROTC and work for a presidenital campaign. (Unlike his father - who is a Republican supporting Eisenhauer's re-election - Richie supports Democrat Adlai Stevenson. Appropriately enough, in the little-seen sequel More American Graffiti (1979), Howard's character is involved in a 1960s campus protest. )


With all the good humor, good stories and good performances in it, it's a shame to report that Happy Days Season 2 is a disappointment on DVD, at least in its presentation. First, many of the shows have been edited for music (music rights being the biggest hurdle - and cost - for studios) and second, the transfers lack the clarity and sharpness of the show's contemporaries. It just seems that CBS/Paramount didn't put a whole lot of effort into this release, which is truly a shame since the show is a cultural landmark and this is one of its finest collections of episodes.


The studio has set up a bad situation for fans, which is truly a no-win scenario. If fans don't buy Season 2, the studio will conclude that further releases aren't warranted. If fans do buy it, the studio will conclude that securing music rights and using the best transfers aren't necessary to make a sale, and fans will face future lackluster releases. What does one do if they want to see their favorite show continue on DVD but in better quality? Well, for one thing, they can support the releases of programs that are done right, like HBO's recent release of Get Smart, Image Entertainment's definitive Twilight Zone collections, or Disney's releases for Lost. Beyond that, the choice becomes whether to see the show continue with releases like Season 2 of Happy Days, or choose to remember the show in its glory, not with muddy transfers and music substitutions.



Still, Happy Days Season 2 contains a fun program that was operating at the top of its game. Despite this set's problems, fans of the show could do worse than these 23 episodes and the nostalgic, funny portrait it paints of an important decade in American history.


Friday, March 30, 2007

DVD Review: Justice League Unlimited Season 2

These aren't the cartoons from your childhood. Those were broadcast on Saturday mornings and featured characters that were flawless, bland and always right. When Justice League Unlimited aired on Cartoon Network, it did so after 10 p.m. on Saturday nights. Its characters, while still heroic, are far from always right, and often find themselves correcting mistakes or resolving self-doubts. They exist in as realistic a world as they can with super-powered aliens and satellites with Star Trek-like technology.

Thirty or forty years ago, superheroes were an extension of law enforcement. They seemed to always operate in daylight and in conjuction with the police or the army. They were simply an extension of the authority figures in the real world, and no doubt were written to reinforce a respect for them. They were the "Super Friends," and with their kid sidekicks, they tracked evil down and vanquished it so the world could be safe in time for a sugar-coated cereal breakfast.

Back around the same time, bland comic book characters were getting a make-over. With Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams, and later Steve Englehart and Marshall Rogers, reinventing Batman as a fearsome creature of the night, the same superheroes that enforced the letter of the law - mostly in daylight - on Super Friends were often breaking the law in comics to realize their own vision of justice. Those creators and more like them in the 70s and 80s begat the film Batman in 1989, with its dark, serious take on the character, which begat the animated series of the 1990s by Bruce Timm and Paul Dini, which might be the best interpretation of the character in its long history.

Timm and Dini also headed up an animated Superman in the 90s, which was also a great reinterpretation of the character. That led to Justice League, and after two seasons, Justice League Unlimited, which allowed them to explore the entire spectrum of the DC universe and all its characters. Hardly any corner of DC's publishing history went unexplored. By the way, this isn't the Justice League of America; rather, it's an organization represented by several nations and more than one planet. It's the League of Nations on a galactic scale.

There's some heavy stuff going on for a cartoon too. A lengthy subplot through much of the series dealt with the government's concern that a group of super-powered beings had banded together to watch over the planet, with a satellite in orbit that could wipe out any portion of it. The government agency and project to discredit the League and its members made for some of the best dramatic moments of the series, not to mention the best conspiracy plots since the days of The X-Files.

You'd hardly expect adult relationships in the midst of the super-people's colored spandex, but they're there. Green Lantern Jon Stewart (a product of comics' reaction to the black power movement) is torn between two different women - one white, one black. Wonder Woman even flirts with Batman and nearly gets him to crack his icy facade. The result of all this is more well-rounded characters who exhibit traits with which viewers could identify. It adds drama to the storylines and intensity to the action.

The Season 2 DVDs look good, as did Season 1. Strangely, although JLU ran for three 13-episode seasons on Cartoon Network, the first 26 episodes were packaged together and labeled "Season 1," while the remaining 13 episodes are here as "Season 2." Whatever the grouping and classification, they're all here and they're as good as you remember them. You might even think the packaging has super-powers of its own, because if you put the thin-designed set on your shelf, it might seem invisible. (The two-disc set is less than half as thick as a standard DVD case.)

If you grew up with the Filmation incarnations of these characters in the 60s (some of which are coming to DVD in June) or the Hanna Barbera-produced Super Friends, you will appreciate the mature, sometimes complex, take on these characters and rich animation from Warner Bros. Throw in a sharp writing team and great voice talents, and you've got some of the best animated shows ever made.

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

DVD Review: Casino Royale

It seems that every few years, there's a movie marketing campaign that attempts to boldly proclaim "Bond is back!" as if Ian Fleming's James Bond ever really went away. Many times, when there was a poor to mediocre movie to promote, the exclamation seemed hollow - another attempt to convince audiences that a return to glory was at hand, summoning their fond memories of past Bond films and raising expectations that this new experience would be like those.

How odd -- and how fortunate for audiences -- that the "Bond is back!" claim is not only true this time around, but that in nearly every way, the latest Bond film exceeds expectations.

Casino Royale is the best James Bond movie in more than 40 years. (We recently named it the best film of 2006 at DVD Comment.) Since the high points of the early Sean Connery films (From Russia With Love, Goldfinger, and Thunderball), the films have seen good movies (The Spy Who Loved Me, The Living Daylights) and bad (A View To A Kill, Die Another Day), but Casino Royale reinvents the series for the 21st century and provides a freshness that has been missing for a long time. (Comparisons to the 1967 Casino Royale with David Niven, Peter Sellers and Woody Allen are not even an issue; neither are comparisons to the 1954 TV Casino Royale with Barry Nelson and Peter Lorre.)

That freshness is personified by Daniel Craig, who was inexplicably vilified by fans on the Internet before filming even began. But while every actor since Connery has brought something to the role, Craig is the first since Connery to make the role his own. His take is different from Connery's - as the others' were too - but he almost makes you feel you're seeing James Bond for the first time. If Craig stays with the role long enough, and his films live up to the quality of Casino Royale, his could be the best run in the series. Critical to the series' success will be more serious spy capers and an avoidance of the self-parody that plagued the series in the past. (The first rule of sequels should always be: Respect the source material and don't engage in parody.)

The story is very faithful to the Ian Fleming novel, the first film in decades to be so. This was Fleming's first Bond book, so it is fitting that the movie version showcases Bond's beginnings. The Bond films have only had the loosest of continuities over the years, so it is not particularly upsetting for longtime viewers to see Judi Dench still portraying M, after having done so for the Pierce Brosnan films. She's good in the role, and that's all the justification needed. Eva Green is also good as Vesper Lynd, the Bond girl who manages to avoid most of the Bond girl cliches from the past 40 years.

The DVD of film looks good, but is so lacking in extras that another edition is inevitable in the future, especially for the highest grossing Bond film of all time. A few short featurettes are included, along with Bond Girls Are Forever, an AMC production hosted by former Bond girl Maryam D'Abo (The Living Daylights). This was already released on DVD in a bonus disc that came with the last Bond movie. It isn't a particularly enlightening documentary and lacks the substance that the bonus materials of MGM's Bond DVDs have had in the past. In perhaps the greatest omission in terms of extras, there are no trailers or teasers present (except for other films!).

Still, until an updated DVD is issued (look for it in advance of the next film in 2008), this edition of Casino Royale is worth your time, since the feature film is the main attraction here and it has substance to spare. Not only is James Bond back to his former greatness, but a new generation has the promise of more great films in series. It hasn't been this exciting to be a Bond fan since The Beatles were making new records.

DVD Review: Neil Young Live At Massey Hall 1971

The second release in Neil Young's Archive Performance Series, Live at Massey Hall 1971 is a pristine recording that sat in the vaults for 36 years. The Archive series, which has long been promised and the first installment of which was only delivered at the end of 2006, was delayed as long as it was because Young was waiting for technology to catch up with his vision for the series. Massey Hall contains the 17-song setlist on one CD and again on a DVD with a video element.

The DVD has a lot of great extras, in addition to video from the concert and superb audio. There are video clips from the Johnny Cash Show and a 1997 video of Young going through material for the Archives. There's radio interviews with Young talking about some of his new songs, and newspaper clippings of reviews from the period. There are many photos and a timeline as well, all of which make a comprehensive snapshot of Young in the early 1970s.

The Massey Hall show was recorded in January 1971, shortly after the release of After The Gold Rush, considered one of Young's very best albums. In fact, this release reveals that Young's producer, David Briggs, wanted Massey Hall to be the follow-up album to Gold Rush, but Young, who had just recorded many of the songs that would make up Harvest, insisted on going ahead with that album instead. What's amazing is that both men were right: Who could argue with releasing Harvest, one of Young's most celebrated albums and the one which gave him his only #1 hit, "Heart of Gold"? But upon hearing Massey Hall - which includes many of the songs from Harvest that made their debut at this show and on the tour from which it came - you can see it being as strong an addition to the Neil Young canon. "On the Way Home," "Tell Me Why," "Journey Through the Past," "There's a World," and "Ohio" are highlights of the set, as is "A Man Needs a Maid/Heart of Gold Suite" which combines two songs from the Harvest album. It's also somewhat refreshing to hear a four-minute version of "Down By The River," which can often reach double that length on live albums.

The video of the concert is a little muddy, as many 36-year-old films are wont to be, but it is no less a gripping visual document of the show. The concert footage is cut with video of the venue and of other locations, such as Young's ranch, which he talks about in reference to "Old Man" and the caretaker the song is about. More intriguing though is the use of the DVD format as a method of archiving. Including those newspaper reviews, pictures, radio interviews and the like shows how encompassing the format can be, and Young is exploring the possibilities. (Indeed, the first box set in the Archive series, set for release in 2007, includes 2 DVDs and 8 CDs, plus a large book.)

Massey Hall remains a great document of a great artist. This is Neil Young at his acoustic best (which is not to dismiss such fine works that followed as Comes A Time, Old Ways, Harvest Moon, Silver and Gold and even the recent Prairie Wind) with the songs that made his solo career get off to such a memorable start. It's historic as part of the artist's past and where he was going at a fertile point in his development, and deserves a place in any Neil Young fan's collection.

Wednesday, March 7, 2007

DVD Review: Borat

High five! Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan is the kind of comedy that movie audiences haven't seen since the high points in Peter Sellers' career. Yes, it's funny as hell; it's also subversive, and more than a little ingenious.

For those that don't know, Sacha Baron Cohen's Borat Sagdiyev is a journalist from Kazakhstan who travels to America to make a documentary film. The clash of his culture and ours is a riot, and it showcases American ignorance, perhaps best exemplified by the racist, sexist college kids that Borat travels with in the film. Or perhaps it's the man in charge of the rodeo, who tells Borat in no uncertain terms what he'd like to see happen to homosexuals if he were in charge. There's any number of examples, really. (Seeing any resemblance to Dr. Strangelove: Or How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Bomb yet?)

Cohen's point doesn't seem to be a mean-spirited one, despite the many lawsuits that have popped up in the film's wake, alleging he duped people into acting stupid. Using satire, he's shining a light on the ugly parts of society and laughing at them at the same time he's pointing them out. Films like Borat usually provoke one of two reactions: either the audience loves it - for the laughs, for the cleverness, for the insight - or they hate it - for pointing out that theirs is not a perfect society. (How many lukewarm reactions can you think of in relation to Dr. Strangelove?) Americans can be notoriously intolerant of people pointing out their foibles, particularly when that someone is from another country (Cohen is British, although many viewers will no doubt confuse him with his character and assume he is from the former Soviet Union).

That the film had an impact is undeniable. How many other movies force the President of the United States to take a meeting with a foreign president trying to manage his country's image? (See link below on Bush's meeting with Kazakhstan President Nursultan Nazarbayev.)

The DVD of the movie offers some worthwhile bonus material, although the limited extras here suggest that another, more expansive edition will be coming at some point. The disc contains 30 minutes of deleted scenes, some of which were cut for good reason (a sequence in a supermarket dairy section goes on too long) and others will make you glad there is a DVD format that contains this sort of thing (Borat's visit to a dog pound is one of those).

The disc's best bits are in the "Propaganda" section, which showcases the promotional tour Cohen took - in character - to promote the film in late 2006. His visit to the White House gate and his statement outside the Kazakhstan embassy are highlights, but it's a shame there isn't more of them. More material than is here was shown on TV (and is on the web) and it adds to the audacity of Cohen's concept and his execution of it.

There's plenty of slapstick in the film, too, if that's your thing, and Cohen plays it as well as the best vaudevillians. The circumstances that Borat finds himself in are often improvised by Cohen, and you have to recognize what a fearless performer he is. He always stays in character and never backs down.

There will no doubt be imitators in the months and years to come, but Borat is the first of this generation's new brand of subversive comedy. It will be shame if those that follow in Cohen's footsteps only produce movies with more gross-out humor and none of his smarts. The lesson that should be learned by comedy writers, performers and studios is that it's the substance behind the film that is its success. Borat shows the mind at work while taking the pratfalls.

Saturday, February 24, 2007

DVD Review: The U.S. Vs. John Lennon

Nearly 20 years ago, the movie documentary Imagine: John Lennon presented a picture of John Lennon's life, from his childhood to his years with The Beatles to his time as a solo artist to his life as a husband and a father. One element in every description of Lennon's life is his outspokenness, which led to political activism when he was in his late 20s and early 30s.

In 1999, Jon Weiner, a professor of history at the University of California - Irvine published Gimme Some Truth: The John Lennon FBI Files. The book chronicled Weiner's attempt since Lennon's death in 1980 to obtain the files that the FBI accumulated on Lennon, mostly when he was a target of the Nixon Administration. The book also reveals that Nixon considered Lennon such a threat to his administration that he was surveilled and an attempt was made at deportation (which arose out of a suggestion from former South Carolina Republican Senator Strom Thurmond).

The new film The U.S. Vs John Lennon chronicles this period in Lennon's life and in American history, but rather than simply being another snapshot of Lennon, this is instead a tale about today and the parallels between the current Bush Administration and its Nixon predecessors. Producers and directors David Leaf and John Scheinfeld have skillfully told the tale of Lennon's activist years with commentary from a variety of knowledgeable sources on the right and the left, and crafted it in such a way that the similarities to the present day are unmistakable. (Indeed, the bonus material for the DVD spends a lot of time explicitly talking about these similarities.) [Leaf, in addition to producing many films about pop culture, is also the author of The Beach Boys and the California Myth, an excellent biography of Lennon's contemporary Brian Wilson.]

The movie tells a compelling story, whether you know of Lennon's fight with the government or not. The paranoia of Nixon and his people has been well-documented over the years, but here - and in Weiner's book - is evidence of all the dirty tricks and underhanded scheming. When Lennon was said to be planning a series of concerts in 1972 to offset the Republican primaries and national convention, Thurmond wrote to Nixon and suggested deportation as a way to prevent political opposition. In the wake of the Vietnam War, the 26th Amendment had been passed, giving the right to vote to all 18-to-21 year-olds, who were thought to be among Lennon's primary audience. Nixon believed Lennon - and by extension, rock and roll music - had real political authority. It's to John Lennon's credit that this was likely very accurate. (As this article about the film in The Nation points out, this idea of activist rock musicians doing an election-related tour sat idle for over 30 years, until the Vote For Change Tour in 2004 by Bruce Springsteen & The E Street Band, R.E.M., The Dixie Chicks, and others who opposed the re-election of George W. Bush.)

Unlike the 1988 movie Imagine (an excellent film in its own right), this film doesn't focus on Lennon's contemporaries in rock music or popular culture to comment on his life. Instead, we hear from Weiner, Walter Cronkite, Carl Bernstein, G. Gordon Liddy, John Dean, Geraldo Rivera, Mario Cuomo, Ron Kovic, George McGovern, Angela Davis, Bobby Seale, Gore Vidal, and Tariq Ali, among others. All of these folks had some contact with Lennon personally in the years addressed in the film, even the likes of Dean and Liddy, who were on the other side - in the Nixon administration - and were following the story of Lennon at the highest levels of government.

Of course, Yoko Ono is also present in the film as a link to John himself. Perhaps no other figure in popular culture has been as unfairly maligned as Ono, who, in the most emotional segment on the DVD (in bonus footage), reads her letter to the parole board concerning Lennon's killer. Any fan of Lennon or The Beatles will be moved.

The extras on the DVD are limited to additional interviews and footage of Lennon, as well as a print interview by Tariq Ali, done in 1971. (Other bonus footage would seem superfluous, anyway, so there is no "making of-" documentary of the documentary and no commentary on the commentaries in the film.) The extra footage is about an hour long, and it is excellent. The majority of it is must-see stuff, particularly the segments titled "Dissent Vs. Disloyalty" and "Then and Now," which make an explicit case that the excesses of power in the Nixon years have been exceeded by the likes of George Bush and Dick Cheney. Only Liddy and Rivera - both right-wing spokesmen who presently earn their living from conservative propaganda outfits - deny the excesses of the present day. Even Dean, Nixon's White House counsel, concedes; although, to be fair, Dean has written recently of his belief that modern conservatives have been co-opted by authoritarian people and ideas.

It's really a shame that these two segments in the bonus material weren't included in the film. Perhaps the filmmakers didn't want to make their point about modern-day parallels so explicitly. (Ironically, Lennon was not someone to hide behind subtleties; the subject of the whole film is him saying what he believed.) The film - taken as a whole on DVD - is much more poignant when one considers the injustices of Iraq, the Patriot Act, the failure of government to respond to Hurricane Katrina, the erosion of civil liberties and the other excesses of power of the Bush administration, with the realization that John Lennon's could have been a strong voice against them. The movie celebrates his spirit and his influence, which is still speaking out, and still in defiance of authority.